The Tiramisu Rule You Should Never Break - Mashed (2024)

ByLauren Rothman/

Ah, tiramisu: that creamy, layered Italian dessert that's basically the very definition of indulgence. We love this smooth, cold confection of ladyfinger cookies, mascarpone cheese, and espresso— enough to take on the formidable, or at least time-consuming, task of making it at home. While whipping up tiramisu isn't complicated, it's still not as quick or easy as busting out a basic pan of brownies: "This is definitely a special-occasion dessert," registered dietician Kristin Carli told Mashed when she shared her recipe.

Aside from being prepared to take on many separate steps — from dipping cookies in coffee to cooking custard over a double boiler to whipping cream— there's another thing you should know before embarking on an afternoon of tiramisu-making. For the creamiest, most balanced result, you must refrigerate the dessert for several hours before digging in, according to Adam and Joanne Gallagher of the popular recipe blog Inspired Taste. The couple writes: "It is so important that you wait at least six hours before serving. In fact, it can be kept refrigerated one to two days and still be delicious." Clearly, tiramisu isn't an instant gratification type of dessert. So why is it so imperative that tiramisu languish in the fridge for so long? Let's find out.

Good things come to those who wait

The Tiramisu Rule You Should Never Break - Mashed (2)

Shutterstock

You know how some dishes, such as soups and stews, seem to taste even better the next day or even days after they've been cooked? That's due to a number of reasons — including chemical reactions in the food— but is often chalked up to something along the lines of a "marrying of flavors," according to Serious Eats. When preparing certain dishes, while they taste great separately, they really shine when, over the course of a few days spent in the fridge, they start to blend together and complement each other. As Dr. Kantha Shelke, a spokesperson for the Institute of Food Technologists, told Forbes, "as the dish cools and sits over time, the different flavor and aroma compounds mingle together and develop more seasoned notes. The individual flavors are still there, but much less pronounced and the dish is therefore more mellow or rounded in flavor."

Well, something similar is at work when your lovingly constructed tiramisu is chilling out in the fridge. Because the dessert consists of layers of different ingredients, each with different flavors — the bland sweetness of the ladyfingers, the bitterness of the espresso, the vanilla notes of the mascarpone custard — it's important to let those flavors mix and mingle before diving in with your fork. As Adam and Joanne Gallagher explainat Inspired Taste, you've gotta "allow the ladyfingers to soak up all the flavors of the creamy filling, coffee, and [Marsala] wine."

Refrigeration is about texture, too

The Tiramisu Rule You Should Never Break - Mashed (3)

Shutterstock

In addition to taste, there's a texture component with tiramisu, as well. The fatty, dairy-rich elements of the dish — heavy whipping cream, mascarpone cheese, even the egg yolks used in the custard — are prone to being runny and, well, flip-floppy when they're not adequately chilled. Part of the "wow factor" of serving a slice of tiramisu is being able to see all those lovingly constructed, alternating layers of ladyfingers and cream: You wouldn't want to go through all the hard work of creating those layers only to serve something too warm which runs out into a sloppy coffee-toned puddle on your cherished guests' dinner plates.

As Carli told Mashed when she shared her recipe, "I recommend refrigerating the dessert so that the tiramisu can chill thoroughly." So the next time you make tiramisu, don't rush the process: the results will be well worth the wait.

Recommended

The Tiramisu Rule You Should Never Break - Mashed (2024)

FAQs

What not to do when making tiramisu? ›

Roberto Lestani, who for the occasion revealed to us the 3 mistakes not to make to prepare a stunning tiramisu!
  1. 1: excessively whipping the mascarpone! ...
  2. 2: once together, don't immediately mix the yolks and sugar! ...
  3. 3: Neglect stratification!
Jun 16, 2020

Why is my tiramisu sloppy? ›

The other main reasons the mixture would be runny is if other liquid ingredients have been added first, or if the mascarpone has been beaten so much that it has curdled (then you will get water separating out from the cheese curds).

What is the summary of tiramisu? ›

Tiramisu (Italian: tiramisù) is an Italian dessert made of ladyfinger pastries (savoiardi) dipped in coffee, layered with a whipped mixture of eggs, sugar and mascarpone and flavoured with cocoa. The recipe has been adapted into many varieties of cakes and other desserts.

How long should tiramisu sit before eating? ›

Repeat the layering of ladyfingers, mascarpone and cocoa powder twice more. Once finished, cover tightly with plastic wrap. Refrigerate for at least 6 hours before serving. If you want to get fancy, finish with a layer of whipped cream piped on top and dust with more cocoa powder.

How to stop tiramisu from going soggy? ›

She uses crisp ladyfingers and subsequently dips them in a mixture of rum and coffee. It is this dipping stage that makes or breaks a tiramisu. According to Garten, if you dip your ladyfingers for too long, they will turn soggy. However, if you don't dip them for long enough, they won't absorb the proper flavor.

Is it better to leave tiramisu overnight? ›

Cover and chill for a few hours or overnight. Will keep in the fridge for up to two days. To serve, dust with the cocoa powder and grate over the remainder of the chocolate.

Is the bottom of tiramisu supposed to be soggy? ›

The perfect tiramisu is a balance between soft elements and fluffy elements, but be careful. The base must be wet but the biscuits must not crush for too much coffee; place the cold coffee in a small bowl and pass the ladyfingers for 2 seconds, the right time for them to get wet without getting too soaked and crushed.

How do you fix curdled tiramisu filling? ›

Once the mascarpone has split it is quite difficult to recover, though if you catch it early (very fine grains) sometimes you can correct it by very gently whisking in (by hand) a little cream.

Why does my tiramisu taste bitter? ›

Because tiramisu contains coffee and chocolate, there is reason to worry that it will taste bitter. But a well-made tiramisu is an exercise in equilibrium. The sweetness of the sugar and mascarpone cheese skillfully counteracts the bitterness of the coffee and cocoa.

What does tiramisu mean in Italian slang? ›

What is Tiramisu? The literal meaning of Tiramisu in Italian is “pick me up” or “cheer me up”.

What country invented tiramisu? ›

These historic memories tell us that the recipe and dessert were well known in Treviso as far back as 1800. As often happens in legends, there are various elements of truth: Tiramisù originates from Treviso, in Italy.

Who eats tiramisu? ›

Tiramisù is the quintessential Italian dessert. Its name hints at its energizing effects, despite sounding slightly risqué in Italian. It is celebrated for its energizing ingredients and is considered a flavor explosion. Some also believe it has aphrodisiac properties, aiding in romantic endeavors.

What is the best liquor for tiramisu? ›

Alcohol: Tiramisu can be made with or without alcohol. This recipe calls for coffee flavored liqueur because I like that it enhances the coffee flavor, but other options are marsala wine or brandy. Make Ahead Instructions: Tiramisu is even better when made in advance, allowing the flavors to blend!

What can I use instead of ladyfingers for tiramisu? ›

Substitute for lady fingers in tiramisu
  • 27 Best Ladyfinger Substitutes. Here is a guide to the best ladyfinger substitutes, such as Pavesini cookies, biscotti, graham crackers, sponge cake, panettone, madeleines. ...
  • 7 Best Ladyfinger Substitutes | Tastylicious!

Why is my tiramisu watery? ›

The right biscuits

As a result, the consistency will be less creamy and slightly more compact. Whichever biscuits you choose, make sure not to soak them too much, otherwise the excess coffee will make the mascarpone cream runny.

How do you keep lady fingers from getting soggy in tiramisu? ›

Garten dips ladyfingers one by one in a mixture of rum and coffee, allowing each to soak for just a few seconds, then quickly moves them to the dish she's using to layer the tiramisu.

Why did my tiramisu curdle? ›

Unfortunately it sounds as if the mascarpone curdled because it was whisked too much. Mascarpone has a very high fat content and so will split more easily than double/whipping cream or cream cheese.

What are the guidelines to be followed in storing tiramisu? ›

How to Store Tiramisu. Leftovers should be refrigerated immediately and will last 4 days. You can either transfer it to an airtight container or wrap the dish well with plastic. If you plan on making this recipe ahead of time, it's best served after 1-2 days.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Wyatt Volkman LLD

Last Updated:

Views: 6293

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (66 voted)

Reviews: 81% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Wyatt Volkman LLD

Birthday: 1992-02-16

Address: Suite 851 78549 Lubowitz Well, Wardside, TX 98080-8615

Phone: +67618977178100

Job: Manufacturing Director

Hobby: Running, Mountaineering, Inline skating, Writing, Baton twirling, Computer programming, Stone skipping

Introduction: My name is Wyatt Volkman LLD, I am a handsome, rich, comfortable, lively, zealous, graceful, gifted person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.