Copy Cat Recipe - Wendy's Frosty (2024)

Comments

• Angie

  Absolutely LOVED this. I used Lactose-free skim milk because of my lactose intolerance & sugar-free chocolate pudding to cut the calories even more, but it came out GREAT, & it was less expensive & had way fewer calories than the real thing. Thanks for posting this. 🙂

  • Budget Savvy Diva

    I am so glad you enjoyed it 🙂 I love it!

• Rachael

  excited to try this tonight. my husband LOVES frosty’s. about how long does it take to re-freeze?

  • Budget Savvy Diva

    For me about an hour – make sure you are mixing it every now and then

• Anne

  Delicious! I didn’t have chocolate pudding on hand but used vanilla instead + about 1 Tablespoon of unsweetened cocoa powder. I also omitted the vanilla extract since I used vanilla pudding. Loved it…thanks so much for sharing!

  • Budget Savvy Diva

    Wahoo! I am so glad you liked the recipe 🙂

    See Also

    Maple Cream Cookies Recipe | Sweet Pea's Kitchen

• georgia

  Do you have the recipe for Apple Pie Bites??Would Love to Have it if you do,

  The Frosty recipe was out of this world, the neareast Wendy to us is 50 miles
  so now I can make them when we want and save on gas. Thank you so much.

  Georgia

• Lulu

  Add a tsp of ovaltine for malt flavor! I find that mine are ready to eat without any additional freezing time when i make these in my magic bullet. So good!

• cyndee

  Actually…. this is what the Wendy’s employees buy when they run out…
  1/2 gal ChocoCharm (Winn Dixie) Chocolate milk (Water based.. & cheap)
  or YooHoo works
  1 can Eagle brand CONDENSED Milk
  12 oz Cool Whip

  Slowly add Condensed milk to chocolate drink (using a hand mixer works best)
  after it is mixed well.. slowly add cool whip… and churn until ready. I like to freeze a Hershey bar and grate it into the mixture after it is finished for a garnish.

• Fun Friday: Fun, Family Recipes 7/13 | Xtreme Couponing With Dee Dee

  […] Copy Cat Wendy’s Frosty Recipe This entry was posted in Recipes, Summer by Dee Dee. Bookmark the permalink. […]

• Copy Cat Wendy’s Frosty

  […] Budget Savvy Diva for a great copy cat recipe of Wendy’s chocolate frosty! Welcome to Simply Frugal! To stay up to date on the best Canadian deals, freebies and coupons, you […]

• joe

  nice near fire on your cutting board…

  • Budget Savvy Diva

    Thank my husband

• Tabbi

  I really loved this recipe. My little brother is diabetic and I made this with sugar free pudding mix; with a little extra insulin, he was able to have a frosty! Delicious!

  • Budget Savvy Diva

    Yay!!!

• 15 Copy Cat Recipes! | Budget Savvy Diva

  […] Copy Cat Recipe – Wendy’s Frosty […]

• Kimberly

  This sounds yummy but we don’t do cool whip in our house. Any ideas for an alternative for this ingredient?

  • Susan Hogan

    Kimberely- I use this recipe and it is great. Can’t stand COOL WHIP!
    http://www.thekitchn.com/restaurant-recipe-homemade-chocolate-frosty-171084

• What's for dinner today?? - Page 1276

  […] Re: What's for dinner today?? Originally Posted by kwhile0599 Thanks Renee! Yeah, can't risk the bed for fear of him falling – I really don't mind sleeping on the floor with him – it keeps him still – he puts his paw on me so I couldn't escape even if I wanted to! I sure could go for a frosty tonight! Just for you 😀 Copy Cat Recipe – Wendy’s Frosty | Budget Savvy Diva […]

• FREE Wendy’s Frosty all 2013 just $1! | Budget Savvy Diva

  […] or TRY my Copy Cat Recipe for Wendy’s Frosty […]

• Amanda

  Thanks so much for this recipe! I am assuming that you use the dry pudding mix, not actually make the pudding and then use it. Is that right? Thank you!!

• Friday Favorites | Taste and Tell

  […] Recipe via Budgetsavydiva.com […]

• No Spend Challenge – Eat “Out” at Home - Simply Frugal

  […] Wendy’s Chocolate Frosty […]

• Sarah

  Has anyone tried this in an ice cream maker?

• Josephine

  pretty simple 🙂 yay. I love to dip fries in wendy’s frosty’s.

• Barbara Platt

  I have to try this one

• Sam

  Can you use something other than cool whip?

• Santini

  Can’t wait to try this one! I love Wend’ys frosty! Thank you for sharing this!

• Yang

  I’m craving for this frosty. I will be making this today after I clock out from work. Thank you so much for sharing this recipe!