17 Halloween Recipes With Candy, co*cktails, and Orange Treats That Are Scary Good (2024)

How to Make Candy Magic at Home

Squash Fondue

Melty, gooey, cheese fondue served in an edible squash vessel will impress your guests however you're celebrating.

Café de Olla Alegría

This take on alegría, a traditional Mexican candy made from puffed amaranth seeds, features the flavors of café de olla, a Mexican style of coffee brewed with cinnamon and orange peel and sweetened with piloncillo, a raw brown sugar with rich molasses flavor.Fuel up with this protein for trick or treating.

Pumpkin Praline Bars

A can of Libby’s 100% Pure Pumpkin Puree is the key to giving chef Ouita Michel's bars their dense, cake-like texture, whether to snack on throughout Halloween week or to serve with a party spread.

Pumpkin Spice Shrub Spritz

You can make Evie Negri-Albert'spumpkin spice shrub(which can be enjoyed without alcohol) using pumpkin puree, pumpkin pie spice, apple cider vinegar, and brown sugar. Add it to a glass of ice with some Prosecco and soda water for the perfect Halloween spritz.

Greens-and-Cheese-Stuffed Cinderella Pumpkin

Inspired by Cassie Piuma's squash spanakopita at her restaurant, Sarma, in Somerville, Massachusetts, this stuffed pumpkin is filled with a nutty, creamy blend of Gruyère and feta cheeses; sweet, anise-scented fennel; and hearty green lacinato kale for a stunning vegetarian main dish fit for any Halloween celebration. After roasting and before stuffing, scrape the inside of the pumpkin to loosen about 3 cups of the sweet, tender flesh to yield a flavorful base for the kale filling. Use a gentle hand when scraping to leave the pumpkin walls intact.

Pumpkin Spice Conchas

In chef Ellen Ramos’ festive recipe, a light and fluffy traditional Mexican concha is blanketed with a crunchy, pumpkin-spiced, seashell-shaped sugar crust.

Kumquat-Riesling Gummies

Make your own orange candy with natural coloring from bright orange kumquats and a puckery, sweet-and-sour flavor. To play up the tartness, F&W food editor Paige Grandjean adds a burst of sour flavor and a craveable quality from a citric acid coating.(These have to stand for a day so plan ahead!)

Sweet Potato Gnocchi

Crowd-pleasing gnocchi can be made ahead to add an orange comfort food at dinner or a party.

Sweet Potato Honey Beer Pie

Dark beer, honey, and spices including turmeric, ginger, and cardamom give pastry cook Nik Sharma's pie rich, complex flavors. This is a refreshingly new dessert for any fall gathering.

Whole Roasted Pumpkin with Green Beans and Red Curry Rice

Rice is cooked to a risotto-like texture inside the pumpkin with red curry paste and coconut milk. Bring the whole pumpkin to the table on a rimmed baking sheet or platter, and spoon the saucy rice, studded with spoonfuls of tender pumpkin, into shallow bowls.

Mini Spiced Pumpkins

These spice cakes look like tiny pumpkins when they're covered with orange glaze and topped with a piece of dark licorice, twisted to look like a stem.

Sugar Cookie and Marshmallow Fluff Ghosts

These adorable white chocolate ghosts from Food & Wine's Paige McCurdy-Flynn are a take on a Danish marshmallow cookie known as a flødeboller. You will need four rimmed baking sheets to make these.

Spiced Candy Corn Crispies

These charming sweet-and-savory rice cereal treats are spicy enough to serve with drinks and sweet enough to satisfy a candy craving.

Dark and Stormy Death Punch

This is Grace Parisi's take on the Dark and Stormy, a classic rum and ginger beer drink. Floating in the punch bowl are round ice cubes made with lychee syrup and lychees stuffed with brandied cherries, which have an uncanny resemblance to eyeballs.

Halloween Whoopie Pies

Tender chocolate cake with a luscious creamy filling is great in any form, especially a crowd-pleasing whoopie pie. These little cakes are dressed in their Halloween finest with orange sashes made by rolling the creamy edges in bright orange nonpareils.

Chocolate Mice

These icky-cute mice feature three kinds of chocolate: semisweet in the creamy, cakey center and white and bittersweet in the crisp chocolate shell.

Soft Apple-Cider Caramels

These chewy treats are like caramel apples in candy form, combining the tangy-sweet flavor of cider with buttery caramel. To create your own spin on them, use a flavored apple cider or add different spices, like ground ginger or black pepper.